How to Increase Insurance Sales: Challenges + Solutions

insuranceiovox insightsconversational intelligence

Salespeople in the insurance industry face challenges like fierce pricing competition and a lack of trust in the industry (to name a few).

But there's a way to solve this.

For one, insurance agents can sell more by offering personalized plans catering to a customer's specific needs.

Additionally, agents can leverage call tracking, a powerful tool that provides valuable insights into the success of your sales efforts.

So, how can you effectively increase insurance sales?

Continue reading as we unpack the five insurance sales challenges and their solutions. Then, we'll share 19 impactful tips to boost sales and introduce you to an innovative AI solution to take your sales performance to the next level.   

This Article Contains:

(Click on a link to jump to a specific section)

5 Insurance Sales Challenges and Impactful Solutions

Insurance agents face several challenges on a day-to-day basis. Here are five common challenges, along with impactful solutions to tackle them:

  1. Fierce Pricing Competition

    Challenge: The insurance industry faces intense pricing competition due to global growth slowing down from 3.4% in 2022 to 2.9% in 2023.

    This pressures service providers across sectors to compete solely on price, squeezing profit margins.

    Solution: The following strategies can help combat pricing competition:

    • Diversify your offerings to go beyond traditional policies.
    • Introduce innovative insurance coverage options that cater to specific customer needs, such as personalized plans and specialized coverage for niche markets.
    • Introduce bundled services that provide added value.
  2. A Lack of High-Quality Prospects

    Challenge: It's not enough to generate a high volume of new leads. The key is finding a genuinely interested prospect who will likely become a paying customer.

    Solution: There's no silver bullet to generating high-quality leads. Instead, consider implementing the following to your lead nurturing strategy:

    • Conduct educational campaigns to raise awareness about the potential risks individuals may face without adequate coverage.
    • Find the right market and tailor your focus to reach potential customers who align with your insurance offerings.
    • Try and customize the type of insurance policies you offer to align with the unique circumstances of a prospective client. This will make your value proposition more relevant and appealing.
    • Establish trust by showcasing positive customer testimonials and reviews. Highlight your track record, financial stability, and commitment to customer satisfaction.
  3. Digital Transformation

    Challenge: The impact of technological advancements on your insurance marketing strategy can render previously practical approaches obsolete. Failure to embrace digital transformation can mean losing out to non-traditional competitors.

    Solution: Embrace technologies like the Internet of Things (IoT) for personalized policies and prevention-based models.

    For example, UnitedHealth provides policyholders with up to $1,000 in annual savings for wearing internet-connected wristbands. Customers earn points for engaging in various activities, which are used to calculate insurance policy discounts.

  4. Lack of Trust in the Industry

    Challenge: Consumers struggle to trust insurance providers due to historically low trust ratings and negative perceptions of financial institutions.

    Solution: Adopt a holistic approach to demonstrate the value of insurance and provide trustworthy advice. Instead of focusing solely on individual insurance products or specific coverage areas, consider the broader context of a customer's needs, risks, and goals.

    Aim to understand the policyholder's situation, including their lifestyle, health, financial status, and personal circumstances.

    For instance, Wellth Insurance offers health coverage and wellness benefits for better mental, emotional, and financial well-being. Members can enjoy online coaching, meditation classes, and healthy meal delivery, leading to healthier and happier lives.

  5. Difficulty Balancing Sales Targets and Customer Needs

    Challenge: Insurance sales agents face the dilemma of balancing sales targets with customer needs, potentially compromising personalized service to meet quotas.

    Solution: To overcome this, agents should:

    Additionally, open communication with sales managers helps set realistic goals aligned with customer-centricity, leading to sustainable growth.

Alongside these impactful solutions, let's explore some practical tips to transform your insurance sales.

19 Effective Tips to Boost Insurance Sales

Whether you're a seasoned insurance broker or just started your insurance company, there's no magical solution to boosting sales.

However, your sales process should be flexible, aligning with the changing needs of buyers and dynamic market conditions.

Keep reading to explore practical tips that can transform your insurance sales.

  1. Build a Solid Foundation
  2. Enhance Product Knowledge and Expertise
  3. Build Trust and Credibility
  4. Use Efficient Sales Strategies
  5. Enhance Customer Experience
  6. Leverage the Power of Automation and Technology
  1. Build a Solid Foundation

    To rise above the competition, you need a thorough understanding of your target market, a compelling Unique Selling Proposition (USP), and evolving with trends.

    Here's how you can build this foundation.

    1. Understand Your Target Market

      Your sales success hinges on how well you know your target market.

      Start by identifying your customer's needs, preferences, and pain points with these techniques:

      • Research and analyze: Use surveys, interviews, and online analytics tools to understand your potential customers better.
      • Segment your market: Split your audience into segments based on common characteristics or needs, like age, industry sectors, and more.
      • Develop buyer personas: Craft detailed profiles of your ideal prospective client. Include demographic information, goals, challenges, motivations, and preferred communication channels.

      From there, you can tailor your sales approach to resonate with their specific needs.

      Remember, your target market keeps changing. Continually assess market trends, emerging needs, and evolving customer preferences.

    2. Refine Your Unique Selling Proposition (USP)

      A USP sets your insurance company apart from competitors in a highly competitive market.

      It can include factors such as your extensive industry experience, personalized service approach, etc. 

      Lemonade insurance demonstrates how a well-defined USP can improve sales.

      "Instant everything. Incredible prices. Big heart" — sounds intriguing, right?

      What sets Lemonade apart is its innovative use of technology, transparency, and lightning-fast claims processing — in just three seconds. Moreover, Lemonade operates on a unique model where any extra premium the company receives goes back into various charitable causes.

      In a nutshell: Your USP must answer, "Why should customers choose you over your competitors?"

      Consider the following steps to communicate your unique value proposition effectively:

      • Study competitor's strategies
      • Find opportunities for differentiation
      • Create compelling value propositions
  2. Enhance Product Knowledge and Expertise

    Did you know that 57% of insurance executives believe speaking to a knowledgeable, friendly sales rep is the best way to maintain customer loyalty?

    You can exceed customer expectations and reinforce their trust in your insurance agency by having your agents hone their product knowledge and expertise. 

    1. Become an Expert in Life Insurance

      Study not just your product but your competitor's offerings too.
      Encourage potential customers to ask you questions that go beyond your sales pitch.

      This will demonstrate genuine care for their well-being, reinforcing your position as a trusted advisor in the insurance industry.

      By becoming an expert in life insurance sales, you can offer personalized recommendations tailored to your client's specific needs, including their situation, budget, and risks.

      Insurance provider Geico excels with this approach, as they tailor insurance options based on their client's unique requirements, leading to 97% customer satisfaction. Emulating this strategy can enhance your agency's service and boost sales.

    2. Train Agents Continuously

      Sales training gives your sales team the tools, techniques, and skills to conquer every sales process step.

      Here are some impactful types of training:

      • Product knowledge workshops: Training sessions should cover policy details, insurance coverage options, and benefits to ensure insurance sales agents can confidently present solutions to potential customers.
      • Sales techniques seminars: Train sales agents to close deals successfully with sales techniques like objection handling and negotiation.
      • Industry trends awareness: Provide training on emerging trends, market dynamics, and competitive intelligence.

      With proper training under their belts, insurance professionals become masters at spotting opportunities, navigating customer interactions, and sealing the deal with finesse.

    3. Track Sales Metrics and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

      Whether it's lead generation, conversion rates, or customer retention, you need to measure sales performance to improve it.

      Sales metrics provide important insights about individual performances that help you set realistic goals for your team.

      To start things off, track three essential insurance KPIs:

      • Quota Rate: This metric measures how well salespeople achieve their assigned sales goals. A percentage indicates their progress towards specific targets within a set time, like a month or a quarter.
      • Bind Rate: The bind rate is the percentage of quotes or proposals converted into an actual sale. It indicates how successful sales efforts are in securing customers and finalizing deals.
      • New Policies Per Agent: This represents the number of new insurance policies each agent successfully sells within a specific period. It shows how productive each insurance agent is in acquiring a new client and expanding the company's customer base.
  3. Build Trust and Credibility

    Insurance sales are all about relationships.

    Here are a few ways to help you forge stronger ones.

    1. Establish a Strong Online Presence

      69% of consumers perform an online search before scheduling an appointment.

      A good website ensures a digital presence for your business and round-the-clock accessibility to customers. 

      But what exactly makes a website stand out?

      A well-designed website generally includes the following aspects:

      • Easy navigation: A straightforward and intuitive menu allows users to find information quickly and effortlessly. Use descriptive labels and logical organization to guide users through your website.
      • Mobile responsiveness: Improve the users’ mobile device experience of your website with a responsive design that adapts seamlessly to different screen sizes.
      • Fast loading speed: Compress images, reduce server requests, and use caching techniques to improve performance and reduce bounce rates.
      • Engaging content: High-quality, relevant, and interesting content keeps visitors interested and encourages them to stay on your website.
      • Clear Call-to-Action (CTA): Place crystal-clear CTAs throughout your website to guide users toward specific actions, such as signing up for a newsletter or purchasing.

      Want to step up your website's reach?

      Take up Search Engine Optimization (SEO) to improve your visibility on search engine results pages.

      By incorporating relevant keywords into your content marketing strategy, building backlinks, and maintaining accurate business listings, agents can attract their target audience to the website.

      This can result in higher online visibility, increased website traffic, and greater customer engagement.

    2. Network In Your Neighborhood

      Being online is great, but personally connecting with your community can boost your reputation as an expert and increase sales.

      The best way to do this?

      Consider diversifying the events you attend. Instead of sticking to the same old insurance functions, explore various opportunities for connecting with potential clients. These events include:

      • Charity fundraisers
      • Community service groups
      • School board meetings
      • Roundtable discussions

      Don't forget to bring your business cards to these events to expand your client database without venturing too far.

    3. Partner with Other Professionals

      To expand your current customer base, consider collaborating with other insurance professionals. Reach out to professionals who serve a similar clientele, such as:

      • Mortgage brokers
      • Real estate agents
      • Accountants
      • Financial planners

      When you establish a lead-sharing partnership with other professionals, your clients will appreciate your ability to connect them with experts who cater to their needs. Simultaneously, these professionals may refer new customers and potential clients to your insurance business.

      It's a win-win situation for everyone involved.

    4. Use Customer Testimonials and Referrals to Your Advantage

      Did you know that 82% of consumers seek referrals when making any purchase?

      This indicates that people value recommendations from others and are more likely to consider products recommended by someone they trust.

      Track the impact of referral sales on your business regularly. If you find that referrals are valuable, consider motivating your satisfied customers to refer more friends by offering rewards like gift cards, free meals, or small policy discounts.

      This can lead to a growing referral network, driving your insurance business' success.

    5. Emphasize Value Over Price

      Since prospects are naturally drawn to a lower price tag, you should offer them the lowest price possible to make the sale, right?

      Well, no. In reality, relying solely on a low price might attract customers but won't necessarily ensure their loyalty. 

      For example, the USAA offers its customers a wide range of value-added services for roadside assistance, identity theft protection, and discounts on other products and services.

      As a result of their focus on value, USAA consistently ranks as one of the most trusted brands in the United States.

      Emphasize the value of your offerings over just the price. Highlight your insurance product's priceless benefits to foster long-term customer loyalty and trust.

    6. Employ Storytelling Techniques

      In the insurance industry, cautionary tales about people who didn’t buy insurance in advance can be helpful when you need to hard-sell a prospect.

      But it's unwise to rely solely on a negative pitch.

      Instead, focus on honing your storytelling skills to create emotional connections with potential customers.

      Share heartwarming experiences, such as life insurance bringing stability to a family in need and providing financial security and peace of mind during challenging times.

      You can use uplifting stories like this to motivate prospects without resorting to fear-based approaches to build trust and lasting relationships.

  4. Use Efficient Sales Strategies

    While meeting targets is always the priority, sales teams must ensure they're doing it in a sustainable and budget-conscious manner.


    Check out some of these tips to craft a lean sales strategy.

    1. Advertise on Social Media Platforms

      Looking to reach a wider audience?

      Social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn provide instant access to a wide user base of potential customers in real time. In 2023, the global number of users hit 4.89 billion.

      But here's where things get even better. Social media platforms offer tools and features that facilitate micro-targeting. This means you can precisely define your target audience based on various parameters such as:

      • Demographics
      • Interests
      • Behaviors
      • Past interactions with your brand

      Such intensive targeting techniques let you engage with the audience most likely to convert into paying customers, saving time and resources.

      Ultimately, social media advertising may have a better return on investment (ROI) than most traditional media.

    2. Cross-Sell to Your Existing Customer Base

      Acquiring new customers is often more expensive than nurturing your existing user base.

      So make cross-selling and upselling a sizable chunk of your insurance marketing strategy.


      Don't hesitate to ask questions while gathering information for an existing client quote. This reveals their hidden needs and desires. Use this information to recommend them related services that genuinely resonate with them.

      For example, a life insurance customer who has recently become a parent may be interested in buying health insurance from you in the future.

      However, you don't want to spam your existing client base with offers for more products as soon as they buy something from you.

      Patience is key.

      Focus on meeting their primary needs first.

      Simultaneously, incentivize your sales team to bring in repeat businesses by making cross-sells and upsells an essential component of their KPIs.

    3. Focus on Customer Retention

      As an insurance sales agent, you must devote time to building stronger connections with your current clientele.

      Ensure prompt availability and offer regular policy reviews to ensure optimal coverage and maximize entitled discounts. This fosters confidence in your services and discourages customers from seeking alternatives for discounts.

      Over time, this approach can cultivate loyalty and sustained revenue growth.

  5. Enhance Customer Experience

    89% of companies consistently delivering "significantly above average" customer experiences outperform their competitors financially.

    And you can join their league, too, by following these tips.

    1. Provide Exceptional Customer Service

      According to a 2022 Zendesk report, 81% of consumers stated that a positive customer service experience boosts their likelihood of making another purchase.

      Here are some valuable tips you can implement to provide exceptional customer service:

      • Improve access: Provide multiple communication channels, like phone calls, live chat, etc., and offer support round-the-clock.
      • Ensure transparency: Avoid jargon and ensure customers understand the policies, coverage, and terms they sign up for.
      • Offer quick claims processing: Speed up the claims process and keep customers updated on the status of their claims.
      • Follow-up: Send follow-up messages after interactions and express gratitude to customers for choosing your insurance services.

      Incorporate these tips to elevate your service level, foster long-term loyalty, increase sales, and generate positive word-of-mouth referrals.

    2. Offer Personalized Experiences

      In a survey by Capco, a global technology and digital consultancy, 72% of consumers would share their usage and behavior data for lower premiums and customized coverage recommendations.

      But that’s not all.

      Another Accenture study found that 58% of consumers would switch their service provider for personalized experiences.

      Use this trend to your advantage.

      Gather more information about your customers with the help of tools that collect and manage insurance policy data from your clients.

      For example, if you sell home insurance, delve into the habits and records of homeowners. This data allows you to offer customized premiums for exceptional home maintenance.

  6. Leverage the Power of Automation and Technology

    Embracing the digital age can enhance efficiency, enable personalized experiences, and provide valuable data insights.

    1. Use Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems

      A CRM system is a software tool designed to collect and manage customer data so businesses can maintain strong relationships with their clientele.

      An up-to-date CRM is key to three fundamental aspects of managing customer interactions and selling insurance:

      • Lead management: Organize and track leads, from initial contact to conversion.
      • Customer qualification: Identify high-value customers and tailor marketing efforts to their needs based on their preferences, purchase history, and interactions.
      • Retention: Track customer interactions, preferences, and past purchases to inform your retention strategy.
    2. Nurture Leads to Maximize Sales

      A staggering 79% of leads fail to become permanent customers due to a lack of nurturing. To stay ahead, implement an automated lead nurturing strategy to optimize your sales cycle.


      Automating this process creates a seamless sales cycle that enables personalized interactions, timely follow-ups, and targeted content delivery.

      For example, you could use a marketing automation tool to track lead engagements and accurately pinpoint their stage in the sales cycle. This allows you to set up email marketing, delivering personalized and timely content based on each lead's interests and actions.

      According to research, implementing a robust email marketing campaign results in a 50% increase in high-quality leads compared to other lead-generation tactics, especially when they subscribe to your email newsletters.

    3. Use a Call Tracking Solution

      A call-tracking solution assigns unique phone numbers to various marketing channels, including online ads and direct mail campaigns.

      But how does this benefit you?

      Use it to track the origin of each phone call and gain valuable insights into your marketing effectiveness, such as:

      • Identifying which campaigns or advertisements generate the highest return on investment (ROI).
      • Optimizing your marketing budget and focusing on the most effective strategies.
      • Gaining a detailed view of customers' interests and engagement.

      With these insights, you can concentrate on the most efficient channels, allocate budgets wisely, and enhance your understanding of customers' preferences.

Thankfully, an easy-to-use call-tracking solution can significantly enhance your sales efforts.

Supercharge Your Sales Performance with iovox

iovox is a powerful call-tracking and conversational AI solution that can be pivotal in the insurance industry.

This advanced platform allows you to transcribe recorded conversations and gain invaluable insights. Use it to identify emerging trends to elevate customer support and overall customer experience.

iovox offers a range of impressive capabilities for your business while enjoying the advantages of conversational AI and speech analytics.

Here are some of the tools' remarkable capabilities:

  1. Call Transcription to Track Trends

    With iovox’s conversational AI, you can analyze customer conversations and pinpoint trends, opportunities, and outcomes on scale.

    This invaluable tool empowers you to:

    • Examine keywords or key phrases from each call.
    • Identify the most sought-after products or services among your callers.
    • Uncover the primary challenges your customers are discussing.

    For instance, with iovox Insights, you can categorize callers who express an interest in specific policies, like retirement planning.

    With this comprehensive knowledge, your insurance agents can strategically send follow-ups tailored to retirement products.

  2. Dedicated Numbers for Personalized Communication

    iovox’s Dynamic Numbers allocates a dedicated pool of phone numbers to monitor website visitors, enabling you to:

    • Track interactions
    • Enhance your ROI
    • Monitor customer journey

    Insurance provider Abeille Assurances attained a 20% cost reduction and a remarkable 20% surge in high-quality insurance leads.

  3. Spot Upsell and Cross-Sell Opportunities

    With iovox software's API, you can use speech recognition and analytics technology to explore keywords. This allows you to understand what services or policies potential leads are interested in.

    The iovox API detects the keywords and phrases that relate to customer needs. Using this information, you can find opportunities to offer additional insurance products related to what customers are already interested in, such as life, home, or auto insurance.

    For example, if an existing customer talks about occupational hazards, you can reach out to them about extending their health insurance to cover workplace accidents.

Want to know more? Learn how to capture new sources of revenue with Conversational AI from iovox

Final Thoughts

Selling insurance is not an easy task. It requires patience, determination, and a data-driven mindset. Your insurance agency will need to invest time and resources into building this skill set among the agents.

And while a focus on training and upskilling is key, you also need a comprehensive toolkit to support agents through the sales cycle. Whether it's CRM or performance management systems, befriend technology to stay ahead of the curve.

The tool to win it all?
iovox's call tracking and conversational AI solutions are a non-negotiable companion to your insurance sales strategy.

With iovox Insights, you can track industry trends, generate high-quality leads, spot upselling and cross-selling opportunities, and enhance the overall customer experience.

Click the iovox WebConnect call button on this page, and let's connect.

You can email us at, connect with us at, or dial the toll-free number within the United States at +1 888 369 9519.

From outside the US, please get in touch by dialing one of these phone numbers:

London, UK +44 (0)20 7099 1070
Sydney, Australia +61 (0)2 8520 3530
Paris, France +33 (0)1 84 88 46 40

Contactez notre équipe dès aujourd’hui pour découvrir nos produits et solutions

Veuillez sélectionner une option:


Envoyez-nous un message et une personne de notre équipe vous contactera dès que possible.
Ou appelez-nous au +33 1 84 88 46 40